Boy Gets Kicked Out of School for His Genes

*subhead*DNA not Denim.*subhead*
I spent many, many, many hours in the lab testing people for mutations known to cause cystic fibrosis (CF). CF is a genetic disease caused by mutations in a gene called the CFTR gene. If a person has a deleterious mutation in both copies of his or her CFTR gene (one mutation inherited from dad, one from mom) then the CFTR protein that he or she produces does not function properly. Without a functioning CFTR protein, the patient produces abnormally thick mucus that collects in the lungs and pancreas causing serious breathing and digestive problems. The average life span for someone with CF is about 30 years with some living into their 40s and beyond.

CF is a common genetic disease. It is estimated that 1 in 29 Caucasians carry a mutation in one of their two copies of the CFTR gene. Those that have only one CF mutation do not suffer from CF but are called carriers because they can pass this gene onto their children. There are over 1500 documented mutations in the CFTR gene and counting.

The sheer variation in these 1500 known CF mutations means that some people have mutations in both copies of their CFTR but do not have symptoms of CF. One of their copies of the CFTR gene works well enough to do the job.

I personally know such a girl. While the two mutations in her CFTR genes suggests that she should be sick (her parents were told that she would be while she was in utero), she is as healthy as any other girl her age. She does not have CF. Nor would any doctor diagnose her as a CF patient.

That is also the case for 11 year-old Colman Chadam. He is a healthy boy with mutations in his CFTR gene who has never been diagnosed with CF. And yet his middle school kicked him out simply because of his genes. (You know the DNA kind. Not the denim kind.)

Why? Because there is another child at the same school that has been diagnosed with CF. Doctors recommend no more than one child with CF attend the same school. The concern is that patients with CF carry bacteria in their lungs that they can spread over distances to other people with CF.

But Colman does not have CF so he does not have the characteristic build up of mucus in his lungs that would harbor such bacteria. His parents simply disclosed his genetics to the school district to be cautious. And now Colman feels the sting of genetic discrimination. From Today:
“I was sad but at the same time I was mad because I understood that I hadn’t done anything wrong,” Colman told TODAY. He added: “It feels like I’m being bullied in a way that is not right.”
It is people like my little friend and Colman that prompted the passing of the Genetic Nondiscrimination Act of 2008. GINA for short. GINA prohibits employers and insurance companies from discriminating against otherwise healthy individuals because of their genetics. (Colman can now get health insurance if he was previously denied.) Unfortunately, GINA does not apply to school districts.

This story is important because it tells us a couple of things. First that there is a general lack of understanding about genetics. As a whole, society has swallowed genetic determinism hook, line and sinker. Genetic determinism is the idea that we are determined by what is in our DNA. If Colman has mutations for CF then he better well have CF. End of story.

But medicine is telling us that genes are not everything. There is something called a clinical diagnosis based on real symptoms that is needed to determine if disease is present. Genetics alone is not enough. Hence GINA.

Second, the genetic determinism that is pervasive in our modern thought makes us vulnerable to the eugenics peddled by those in ivory towers. Just like it was back in the early 20th century. With our flawed understanding of genetics, we are more likely to fall for the wares of the likes of Dr. Julian Savulescu who says we can, and should, be screening embryos for those that will have the "best life." Based on their genetics alone, Savulescu argues that we should not only choose the embryos that will be healthy but also the ones that will be kinder, gentler, and more moral. As if these characteristics are based on genetics alone.

As an embryo, Colman certainly would not have not met Savulescu's criteria for having the "best life." It would have been: two mutations in the CFTR gene? Into the trash with you!

So what are we to do? Besides prayer, I am thinking a day where everyone in America is required to watch Gattaca might be in order. I am sure Colman will be able to relate.

Rebecca Taylor blogs at Mary Meets Dolly


  1. So if they "screen" out all but the kindest, gentlest and most moral embryos, will the next generation ban embryo "screening" once and for all, being kind, gentle, moral people who don't like living in a society built on the bodies of their little siblings? It's an interesting thought experiment, isn't it? Once again, the culture of death has run into a philosophical dead end.

  2. This sucks. Children are kicked out from school because of what their sickness? The other boy wasn't even ever diagnosed!

  3. My daughter's Catholic high school has a "Super Dance" every year to raise money for CF research. They have done it for over 30 years because a family had several children who died of CF while they were students there in the 1970s. Those kids know a LOT about the disease, so maybe there is hope that some of them will get jobs where they can influence legislation.

  4. Rebecca, what happens when there are two kids with CF in the same family? Do the doctors just figure that there's nothing they can do about the bacteria problem, or are such families taught to take special hygiene precautions?

  5. Doc,

    I believe siblings are considered to have the same bacterial flora so CF patients from the same family attend the same school. I don't know what precautions are recommended at home for families where more than one child has CF. I imagine hand hygiene and cleaning of any respiratory equipment in the home would be standard practice.

  6. Two of my seven have CF and they have different "bugs" because they go to different places and do different things. They do not share toothbrushes (!) and equipment is boiled. This is normal CF care, even with one child. Blog plug: because this is all so infuriating...
    (And I remember Mendel's pea plants from high school biology; who are these public educators that do not understand?)

  7. The diocese where I once lived, back in the 1990s, ordained to the priesthood a widower who had had 10 children -- 4 of whom had CF. The CF children all died young (one at age 12 and the others in their 20s). I believe this priest is now deceased, but it would have been interesting to get his perspective on this matter. He had been a dentist by profession before entering the priesthood so he had some level of knowledge about medical matters.


  8. What is the matter with people? Why do people live by rules and ignore common sense? Rules are supposed to be general guidelines, and common sense is supposed to guide applying them. It is so sad to hear such stupidity.


Post a Comment